1) the ideas of individuals in Platonism, 2) the problem of the infinity of the intelligible world, 3) the periodical character of the world’s process, 4) individual qualities in Stoicism and Plotinus, 5) the coexistence of indistinguishable individuals. As a result, the author comes to the following conclusions. The goal of Plotinus this treatise was to examine the famous school question in the context of his own metaphysical system (1). Plotinus does not accept the existence of ideas of individuals (2), explaining all features of individuals by the difference in the dominance of certain logoi over matter (3). According to Plotinus, the number of souls is limited, but even if it were infinite, this would not affect the completeness and perfection of the Intelligible world (5). Two indistinguishable individuals can coexist in one world period (6).
Keywords: Ideas of Individuals, Individuation, Plato, Aristotle, Stoics, Plotinus, Palingenesis
For citation: Volkova, N.P. “Plotin ob ideyakh individov” [Plotinus on the Ideas of individuals], Filosofskii zhurnal / Philosophy Journal, 2020, Vol. 13, No. 1, pp. 5‒19. (In Russian)
Adam, J. The nuptial number of Plato: its solution and significance. London: C.J. Clay and Sons, 1891. 84 pp.
Armstrong, А.Н. “Plotinus’ Doctrine of the Infinite and its Significance for Christian Thought”, Downside Review, 1955, No. 73, pp. 47‒58.
Armstrong, A.-H. (ed. and tr.) Plotinus, The Enneads, Vol. V. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press,1984. x, 321 pp.
Blumenthal, H.J. “Did Plotinus Believe in Ideas of Individuals?”, Phronesis, 1996, Vol. 11, No. 1, pp. 61‒80.
Bugai, D.V. Edinstvo platonovskogo ‘Gosudarstva’ [Unity of Plato’s ‘Republic’]. Moscow: A.V. Vorob'ev Publ., 2016. 452 pp. (In Russian)
Chiaradonna, R. “Plotinus on Sensible Particulars and Individual Essences”, Individuality in the late Antiquity, ed. by A. Torrance and J. Zachhuber. Farnham: Ashgate Publ., 2014, pp. 57‒47.
Clarke, W.N. “Infinity in Plotinus: a Reply”, Gregorianum, 1959, No. 40, pp. 75‒98.
Cornford, F. Plato’s Cosmology. Indianapolis; Cambridge: Hackett Publishing Company, 1935. 377 pp.
Erhardt, E. “The word of the muses”, Classical Quarterly. New Series, 1986, Vol. 36, pp. 407‒420.
Gerson, L. (ed. and tr.) Plotinus, The Enneads. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017. 931 pp.
Harder, R., Beutler, R., Theiler, W. (Hrsg.) Plotin, Schriften, Bd. I. Hamburg: Felix Meiner Verlag, 1956. 359 S.
Henry, P., Schwyzer, H.-R. (eds.) Plotini Opera, Vol. II. Oxford: The Clarendon Press, 1977. xxxvi, 302 pp.
Kalligas, P. “Forms of Individuals in Plotinus: A Re-Examination”, Phronesis, 1997, Vol. 42, No. 2, pp. 206‒227.
Mamo, S. “Forms of Individuals in Enneads”, Phronesis, 1967, Vol. 14, No. 2, pp. 77‒96.
Rist, J.M. “Forms of individuals”, The Classical Quarterly, 1963, Vol. 13, No. 2, pp. 223‒231.
Ross, W.D. (ed.) Aristotle, Metaphysics, Vol. I. Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1924. clxvi, 366 pp.
Sedley, D. “The Stoic Criterion of Identity”, Phronesis, 1982, Vol. 27, No. 3, pp. 255‒275.
Stolyarov, A.A. Stoya i stoitsizm [Stoa and Stoicism]. Moscow: KAMI Grup Publ., 1995. 444 pp. (In Russian)
Sweeney, L. “Infinity in Plotinus Part 1”, Gregorianum, 1957, No. 38, pp. 515‒535.
Sweeney, L. “Infinity in Plotinus Part 2”, Gregorianum, 1957, No. 38, pp. 713‒732.
Sweeney, L. “Plotinus Revisited: a Reply to Clarke”, Gregorianum, 1959, No. 40, pp. 327‒331.
Volkova, N.P. “Ot idei cheloveka kak vida k ideyam individov” [From the Idea of Human Being as Species to the Ideas of Individuals], Mera veshchei. Chelovek v istorii evropeiskoi mysli [The Measure of Things. Man in the History of European Thought], ed. by G.V. Vdovina. Moscow: Akvilon Publ., 2015, pp. 19‒54. (In Russian)